This provision has not been checked by a human. The text below was read automatically from the official PDF and has not yet been verified against it, so it may differ from the provision as published — in its wording, its numbering, or where one provision ends and the next begins. For the authorised text, see legislation.vic.gov.au.
inserts a definition of the evidence to which the "credibility rule" in clause 102 applies. "Credibility" evidence is either evidence that is (a) relevant only because it affects the assessment of the credibility of the witness or person, or (b) relevant because it affects the assessment of credibility and is relevant, but not admissible, or cannot be used, for some other purpose under Parts 3.2 to 3.6 of the Bill. Paragraph (b) has been inserted to address the decision of the High Court of Australia in Adam v The Queen (2001) 207 CLR 96 (Adam). Prior to Adam, the provisions in Part 3.7 controlled the admissibility of evidence so that the credibility rule applied if evidence was relevant both to credibility and a fact in issue, even where the evidence was admissible for the purpose of proving a fact in issue. Adam considered section 102 of the UEAs, which is in effect, the same as clause 101A(a) of this Bill. The result of that decision is that control of evidence for more than one purpose, including credibility, depends entirely upon the exercise of the discretions and exclusionary rules contained in clauses 135 to 137. This has the potential to lead to greater uncertainty, inconsistent outcomes and increased appeals. The introduction of the elements in clause 101A(b) make evidence relevant to both credibility and a fact in issue, but not admissible for the latter purpose, subject to the same rules as other credibility provisions. Clauses 101A and 102 are in accordance with the 2005 LRCs' Report (recommendation 12-1). The Note to clause 101A clarifies that clauses 60 (exception to the hearsay rule) and 77 (exception to the opinion rule) are not relevant in the determination of admissibility for another purpose under clause 101A because they cannot apply to evidence which has not yet been admitted. The inclusion of this note is in response to the decision in Adam. Division 2—Credibility of witnesses This Division deals with the "credibility rule" and additional protections and exceptions to that rule.